Search the site...

OPTIMISTIC DISCONTENT
  • Home
  • Curriculum
    • Curriculum Framework
    • Unit Design >
      • Standards >
        • National Visual Arts Standards
        • New! Missouri Visual Arts Learning Standards
      • Unit & Priority Standards
      • Enduring Understandings
      • Unit Themes
      • Essential Questions >
        • EQ Examples: Overarching
        • EQ Examples: Topical
    • Assessment Design >
      • Scoring Guides
      • Proficiency Scales
    • Lesson Design >
      • Inquiry-based Lesson Design
      • Teaching through Inquiry in Art
      • Inquiry-based Lesson Structure
    • Unit Examples >
      • Elementary Units
      • Middle School Units
      • High School Units
    • Resources
  • Presentations
    • Speaker Request Form
  • About
    • Thought Blog
  • Contact
  • Community
  • Home
  • Curriculum
    • Curriculum Framework
    • Unit Design >
      • Standards >
        • National Visual Arts Standards
        • New! Missouri Visual Arts Learning Standards
      • Unit & Priority Standards
      • Enduring Understandings
      • Unit Themes
      • Essential Questions >
        • EQ Examples: Overarching
        • EQ Examples: Topical
    • Assessment Design >
      • Scoring Guides
      • Proficiency Scales
    • Lesson Design >
      • Inquiry-based Lesson Design
      • Teaching through Inquiry in Art
      • Inquiry-based Lesson Structure
    • Unit Examples >
      • Elementary Units
      • Middle School Units
      • High School Units
    • Resources
  • Presentations
    • Speaker Request Form
  • About
    • Thought Blog
  • Contact
  • Community

What does it mean to be Developmentally Appropriate in Art?

1/22/2018

0 Comments

 
As good teachers are apt to do, whenever you sit down to plan lessons or activities for your students, you keep in mind where they are in their learning.  Where do their abilities typically lie? What are students of this age group interested in learning about? What would build their learning and experiences from last year through to next year? What would challenge and motivate them? How can I excite them and foster their curiosity?

All of these questions also come up when we write curriculum.  What I especially appreciated when we were examining standards this time was how developmentally appropriate the National Visual Arts Standards are. The writing team must have taken time to thoughtfully consider not only how to scaffold skills in each artistic process, but also where students of each grade are typically  at in their physical, social-emotional, language and cognitive abilities and development.  When we first started writing curriculum using these new standards, we received a little push back about how we were challenging our kids. We often heard we weren't being "developmentally appropriate" in the tasks that we were asking students to participate. Although this feedback was in reality from a few outliers,  when you are trying something new, you can be more susceptible to criticism. "Are we doing the right things for our kids?" "What exactly does it mean to be developmentally appropriate anyway?" "What does that look like for my students?"  

Being developmentally appropriate means teaching with a respect to the typical growth at a certain age and addressing the needs of an individual child; looking at the "whole child," including intellectual, social, emotional, physical, and creative growth. We address a wide range of skills in an art class - fine motor skills, language skills, reading and writing skills, social skills, cognitive processing, creative and critical thinking, reasoning... just to name a few! We have a number of spinning plates to keep our eyes on. ​
Picture
Picture
To help with this herculean task, I was recommended a fantastic book, Yardsticks: Children in the Classroom Ages 4-14. Yardsticks by Chip Wood offers age-by-age characteristics of typical child development in multiple areas. Although it doesn't have specific developmental stages for art skills set aside in its own category, it does have lots of information applicable to what we need to know and be aware of as we shape learning in our art classes, including social-emotional growth, fine motor skill development, and cognitive abilities. I find it to be very practical, insightful, and a helpful resource to have around as we write learning experiences for our students. To echo an endorsement from the cover, it truly does help teachers be responsive to the needs, talents, and aspirations of the children we teach. 
Keeping these needs in mind, we can better develop a course that fits the child as opposed to making the child fit the course. The arts truly are integral to allowing students to stretch and grow, if we let them.  How do you feel about your curriculum and the way it fits your students? Are you able to meet their specific individual needs while also encouraging and fostering their skill development and growth? I'd love to hear more about the needs of your students and how you structure a curriculum to meet them in the comments below... ​
0 Comments

SHould Art Education be for Profit?

1/10/2018

1 Comment

 
Recently, PBS News Hour had a segment titled, "Why teachers selling lesson plans have sparked debate" that started conversations online about the nature of teachers making a profit off lesson plans and materials. As an art teacher, I have had to make many of my own lessons and materials, as I know other art teachers have done. I have had many conversations with high school teachers from other subjects such as ELA, Math, Science, Social Studies, etc. over the years about why I can't "just go the teacher's manual or materials" for the hand out or activity I want to do with my students. Most of the time that doesn't exist. Or I should say, it didn't exist. (and as a side note, most of the time, wasn't the type of thing I was really looking for...art needs way more engaging materials than a fill in the blank worksheet!)

With the rise of Pinterest and social media connecting more and more art teachers across the country, reaching out to others for ideas became easier and easier. Sometimes it is an open request on a forum for help or examples, other times it is a direct ask through email, and an even easier way is by following the ever growing number of blogs and websites run by art teachers that are sharing the fantastic and exciting things going on in their classrooms. So many generous teachers are adding to the collective, supportive environment of art education by sharing ideas and materials openly - without a paywall. Now while I don't begrudge teachers finding a way to supplement their (too low) income by using their professional skills, I am also a big believer in collaboration and putting good out into the world. If we stopped sharing and always insisted on getting paid, the collective strength in our profession would be diminished.  We need to be willing and open to give away some ideas, because, let's face it...not everything we do is truly 100% original. We do not work in a vacuum, we stand on the shoulders of giants, influenced by the ideas of others whether that be by artists, other art educators, or our students. Now, do we deserve to be compensated for our time and expertise when it comes to being adept at graphic design, layout, etc. and when we create a reproducible? Sure. But personally, I have always believed that we should give as much as we take. So if I have benefited from the inspiration, help, and materials from others, I should be turning around and offering as much to others. 
Picture
Considering this issue, I can't help but think about the units Melissa Purtee and Ian Sands have offered up when thinking about how to teach artistic behaviors, specifically 'Artists Steal', as well as Austin Kleon's book, Steal Like an Artist.  When do we "borrow" and at what point do we straight up "steal" from other art teachers? There was a recent dust up relating specifically to an art teacher's lessons that another art teacher was posting on TPT and charging for them.  Luckily, because the lessons were so well documented on his open blog and because someone let him know they recognized them as his, he was able to put a stop to someone profiting off his intellectual and physical property.  Many comments by many art educators I respect and admire lamented this type of 
behavior and even said it makes them wary to share as openly as they do. Does the existence of sites that charge for lessons then unintentionally promote unethical behavior?  Do we continue to share as openly as we do, even if it means others may profit without us? Do we band together to continue our virtual PLN and stand stronger together, sharing materials as opensource goods and promoting good ethics and practices in art education?  How do we keep each other in the right frame of mind to benefit as many students in art as possible? I'd love to hear others thoughts in the comments. ​​
1 Comment

Happy New Year!

1/1/2018

0 Comments

 
We are all inundated with year end countdowns, best of lists, and articles about resolutions for the new year ahead. ​ This time of year always has me reflecting on my life, my relationships, and my work. What do I want to focus on? Where could I be more or do better? I implement a couple of strategies to help in making my resolutions stick a little better and stay with me. One is that I have a public resolution that is reflected in a single word. You may have heard about this from various hashtags on social media, #oneword2018, or associated with a couple of different books out there. In short, it is a movement to consolidate your long list of resolutions into one simple word and to look back throughout the year to this one word to remind you of your resolution.  

​I like to give myself a few days into the new year to try on my possible words and see which one resonates the most.  I am rolling a few over in my mind and I am thinking the word for 2018 will be GROW. I love this message from Neil Gaiman about mistakes. It reminds me to push myself, to try new things and make an impact on the world around me. It encourages me to push through fear, to learn through mistakes, and to embrace failure because through these experiences we can take away much more than quickly succeeding. These are also things that resonate with me as an artist. I have to be willing to try out new ideas and put myself out for others to see, to interpret, to analyze. I sometimes have to play with ideas, to experiment, to throw things against a wall and see what sticks. 

​
 
Picture
Picture

​​Modeling this grit is also really important for me to do for my students. They need to see models of how others face fears, embrace new passions, develop their craft. I need to embrace my discomfort to empower others to do the same for their own development and growth. I need to put forth my own willingness to learn and grow. 


I like to also take my resolutions on a month-to-month basis. If at the end of January, my one word no longer suits me and the direction I want to go in 2018, I give myself permission to find a different word. Or perhaps if the word still applies, I will look at it through a different lens.  I plan on starting GROW with some focus on self and dedicating time to mindfulness in order to grow. I am going to end each day with at least 5 minutes to mindfully draw in my sketch book along with the Art of Mindfulness Drawing Challenge. Whenever I have set aside time to do this sort of unplanned drawing, I have definitely noticed a positive impact on how stressed I feel. Better yet, I try to incorporate it with my own kids right before bedtime, and I've noticed they really enjoy it and calm down for the evening.
How will you approach the new year?  Do you set resolutions to guide your path in the new year?  Is this a time you use to reflect? I'd love to hear more in the comments!

Happy New Year!
​~M
0 Comments

Make It Your Own

12/18/2017

0 Comments

 
​Over the years, I have introduced myself to a number of groups and have often been asked how I feel about stepping out of the classroom and away from interactions with students. I miss working on a daily basis with students immensely, but I also really enjoy getting to step back and really think about the way, the what and how we teach art. I am deeply passionate about teaching and about art, and about art's importance in our lives. I have often said I have a sick fascination with curriculum and that is because what we teach our kids, and how we plan to experience it with them can be incredibly fun! I like diving into the questions we might use to inspire them and what big ideas will excite them. I like thinking about my own practice and what that might bring to the table for students.  And because I think it is so important that students of all ages are able to experience arts learning, I think it is important that we think about how we engage students and what they are learning about. 

This all, however, takes time and in our school district we are lucky to have a position dedicated specifically to curriculum and instruction  in the arts. I know that few districts have a position  
Picture
like this and that leaves many teachers with questions about curriculum, assessments, and best practices in instruction.  My hope is that if you have found your way here that you will be able to use what I share as a resource, using it as you think about your own students and try it out in your classroom. I believe the best lessons are the ones that we are able to put a personal stamp on, thinking about how we might personally interpret it and in turn share with our students. I am reminded of the  Art of Ed podcast host, Tim Bogatz, and how he tells his students to "make it their own." The same goes for lesson plans or unit ideas you hear from other teachers. Delivering a lesson straight off a page without first internalizing your own thoughts about it is a recipe for disaster.  Sometimes all it takes is a small tweak to infuse an idea with our own voice, and sometimes the circumstances and situations in your classroom require major changes to really make it fit. 

My desire with the units and lessons I share is to provide just one example of how the National Core Arts Standards can be taught, looking at the big picture of an entire year (and eventually an entire K-12 span). I know there are many, many, many different ways that incredible art teachers all over the country are using the NCAS to engage their students with the artistic process and artistic literacy, and I would love to hear how others are doing it. What big ideas do you use? How do you connect artists and art history? How kind of juicy questions are your students tackling? How do you engage them in creative and critical thinking?

Leave me a comment sharing your ideas and what you are doing. Or if you try some of the lessons or units how did you make it your own? I can't wait to start a conversation about it. 

~Michelle

0 Comments

Well, this is new...

12/9/2017

1 Comment

 
Welcome to this website and my blog! This project is simultaneously exciting and terrifying. An introvert by nature, letting people inside my thoughts can sometimes be uncomfortable and make me quite nervous. Other times my opinions spill over quite readily and I am usually always willing to share what I know if it will help someone else out. Especially if it helps kids and students come to love and learn about art and the world. 

My intention with this website is to provide art teachers and administrators with a resource that can help them when creating curriculum and assessments as well as resources to help with instruction. While I know there is a lot I don't know, and that I am limited by my own experiences, I also know that I have encountered many people who have questions that I can help answer. While there isn't always one right way to do things, there are some practices and methods that have proven to be successful for myself and others that I want to explore and share. There are so many moving parts in our world of teaching art. While the website isn't completely finished, and may be continually evolving, I hope you will come back to check it out often and find it useful as you practice your craft.
The blog part of this website will be my open thoughts and responses to topics as they come across my world. I love to read, listen to podcasts, and visit places where I can observe the world and see cultures and, of course, art!

​Speaking of podcasts, one of my favorites that I was too slow to start listening to was the Art of Ed Art Ed Radio Podcast. 
 
Picture
They cover some fantastic topics and have great guests that talk about all sorts of relevant issues we face in the art room. ​ I typically like to listen to this one as I drive to or from our state art ed conferences. It gets me in the right frame of mind to get my art ed learning on! But, I've also recently started to listen as I get ready in the morning. ​It starts my brain buzzing and jump starts my own questions and thinking. 

I hope that like the way this podcast series gets me thinking and reflecting, that this website can also do the same for you. I'd love to hear from anyone that is using this website, or reading this blog, and start talking about what we are seeing in our art rooms.  Everyday is an adventure and I am really looking forward to this one! 

Take care,
​Michelle
1 Comment
    Picture

    Hello!

    I'm Michelle. I am very excited to try my hand at blogging and sharing my thoughts and reflections in the field of art education. 


    Picture

    Original NAEA Blog Posts

    NAEA Blog Posts
    ​
    I started blogging at the invitation of the National Art Education Association for their Monthly Mentor column. See those original blog posts here.
    See more...

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly